logo

Diamond & Jewelry News, Advice and Prices for Consumers

Resolved Question

Show me another
JohnA April 26, 2010

Can a wedding and engagement band be made out different materials?

My boyfriend gave me platinum diamond engagement ring, which I adore, but we went to pick out wedding bands the other day and our favorite wedding bands were made from yellow gold. Since yellow gold and platinum have a slightly different shade, I'm afraid the yellow gold wedding band will clash with my platinum engagement ring.

Answers (1 - 6 of 6)

DebraT October 20, 2010

Sorry, but I think you should try to make your engagement ring and wedding band match. You are planning to wear them together right?

Having them two separate colors may look kind of weird. This is something that you will most likely be wearing for a long time. You should want it to look good.

TravisE October 20, 2010

Absolutely. There is no written rule that states that the engagement ring and wedding band need to be made out of the same material. You may want to make sure that they blend nicely if you decide that you will be wearing them both simultaneously though.

JeffreyR June 4, 2010

Of course they can be made of different precious metals! When you think about it, you'll be wearing your engagement ring and your wedding band for the rest of your life so you might as well have some variety. Some people like to have their wedding ring and engagement ring match and even set on the same finger, but it is truly a matter of personal preference. I like to see each ring get the attention it deserves, which is why I'm all for having an engagement ring made of one metal (like platinum or white gold) and a wedding band made of another (like yellow gold or titanium).


Just because your engagement ring is not made from the same precious metal as your wedding band does not mean that they have to clash. White gold for an engagement ring and two shades of gold (white and yellow) could be an interesting option that doesn't clash for example. Once you decide on the metal you would like for your engagement ring, you can simply try to have that metal appear somewhere in your wedding band as well. You can always take the advice of an experienced jeweler if you want to get a professional opinion.

RICHARDL May 24, 2010

For sure. Since wedding bands are less subject to trends and fashion fads due to their tie to holiness, and religion, and their central role in the actual ceremony, most couples typically stick with modest yellow gold wedding bands. However, engagement ring trends are constantly changing. The only thing expected from an engagement ring is that it include diamonds, and even that isn't a "must" these days. For these reasons, many couples choose yellow gold wedding bands, and pick out platinum or white gold bands for the diamond engagement ring. I would even say it is typical that couples wear wedding bands and engagement rings made with different materials.

RobertL May 12, 2010

Of course they can. It is true that traditional wedding bands and engagement rings were made out of yellow or white gold, and were set with diamonds, however, that is not the rule. Nowadays, innovatively designed alternative metal engagement rings and wedding bands have become increasingly popular. You can find more and more engagement rings and wedding bands made out of platinum, titanium (which is also called the space metal) and even wood and plastic. My engagement ring, for example, is made out of petrified wood and was hand carved, whittled and painted by my husband. I find the ring charming, incredibly personal and sentimental. Some people may not approve of my unconventional engagement ring or wedding band, but I know it was made with love and care, specially for me, and that makes all the difference.

EdwardR May 9, 2010

Sure why not! You should go with what you like. Even if you go with a yellow and white gold engagement ring, which would look very dissimilar, it would still be your style and your personal preference. It doesn't necessarily have to look tacky or in cohesive. You could ask a jeweler to help pick out which different precious metal engagement ring setting would look nice together but ultimately you should go with whatever precious metal you think suits you best.